The votes for your favorite tinted moisturizer were incredibly close, with less than 40 votes separating first and second. But the Laura Mercier Tinted Moisturizer has been crowned as the victor.

Full disclosure: Though I didn’t cast a vote for any, the Laura Mercier Tinted Moisturizer was my first and only tinted moisturizer in my makeup routine. I haven’t used it in years, but I’m glad to see it still hooks people in the way it did me.

Here’s what you all had to say about it:

My sister gave me a sample tube and I used it for the first time over the weekend - when I first put it on I was like “this doesn’t even look like I put anything on my face” (not a positive!) but when I looked in the mirror later I was like WOAH WHAT - it somehow EVOLVED from pretty much NO coverage whatsoever to a nice light evening-outness and so I say TWO THUMBS UP -catherinethesecond

Laura Mercier is the only one that doesn’t ball up on my stupid face. I vote her. - Annie from the Grog Booth

I got it as a sample and figured I’d keep it for whenever but then I used it once and fell in love. I’m nearly out of my sample tubes, gonna have to bite the bullet and buy full-size during the April sale. - unicorndragonlady

I agree with this. I love my Laura Mercier. - cyanpineapple